| YEAR | CLUB |
| 2020 | Steve Donaldson | Umina United SC |
| 2019 | Pete Edwards | Gosford City FC |
| 2018 | Jorge Chavez | East Gosford FC |
| 2017 | Michael Penn | Umina United SC |
| 2016 | Dave Hurley | The Entrance FC |
| 2014 | Cris Berrios | Budgewoi FC |
| YEAR | CLUB |
| 2020 | Steve Donaldson | Umina United SC |
| 2019 | Pete Edwards | Gosford City FC |
| 2018 | Jorge Chavez | East Gosford FC |
| 2017 | Michael Penn | Umina United SC |
| 2016 | Dave Hurley | The Entrance FC |
| 2014 | Cris Berrios | Budgewoi FC |